Skip to main content

Inheritance and composition


  • Inheritance is used for
    • Code resuse
    • To support polymorphism
  • Disadvantages of inheritance
    • Difficult to change the interaface of the subclass
    • Superclass is always instantiated
    • Can get complex and unmanageable
  • Composition is used for code reuse
  • Disadvantages of composition
    • We cannot use polymorphism
    • We cannot extend the system by adding subclasses
    • May have a slight performance overhead
  • Usage
    • Inheritance: IS- A
    • Composition: HAS - A

Example 1:

public class Car {
  private Engine engine;
  public void start() {}
  public void stop() {}
}

public class SUV extends Car{
  public void start() {} //overrides the start method from Car

  public void fourByFourMode() {}
}



Example 2:
public void someMethod() {
  Car c = new SUV();
  c.start();
}



Example 3:
public class Car {
  private Engine engine;
  public void start() {
    engine.start();
    //maybe do something more
  }

  public void stop() {}
}
Java2html

I will end this post with the first paragraph from Item 17, of Joshua Bloch's excellent book, Effective Java. In the book this paragraph is followed by a code example that explains this very well, however, I am not sure if I can include the example under fair use. Crying..

Inheritance is a powerful way to achieve code reuse, but it is not always the best tool for
the job. Used inappropriately, it leads to fragile software. It is safe to use inheritance within
a package, where the subclass and the superclass implementation are under the control of the
same programmers. It is also safe to use inheritance when extending classes specifically
designed and documented for extension (Item 15). Inheriting from ordinary concrete classes
across package boundaries, however, is dangerous. As a reminder, this book uses the word
“inheritance” to mean implementation inheritance (when one class extends another).
The problems discussed in this item do not apply to interface inheritance (when a class
implements an interface or where one interface extends another).

Can you think of a situation where subclassing an existing class can break the semantics of your code, because of a certain undocumented feature of the superclass? Let me give you a hint. Assume a collection class has 2 methods

add(Object o) - to add the specified object to the collection

addAll(Collection c) - to add each element of the specified Collection to this collection.

Now assume that addAll(Collection c) internally invokes add(Object o) for every object in the collection.

Can you think of a situation that will result in a bug, if we subclass this class and override the above methods to add a functionality that keeps track of how many elements have been added to the collection?

Resources:

  1. Compostion vs. Inheritance
  2. Composition and interfaces

Note: This text was originally posted on my earlier blog at http://www.adaptivelearningonline.net

-----
COMMENT:
AUTHOR: Josh Bloch
EMAIL:
IP: 71.202.105.255
URL:
DATE: 09/29/2007 10:22:58 PM
Yes, you can include the example under fair use:)

Josh
-----
COMMENT:
AUTHOR: Parag
DATE: 10/02/2007 09:17:55 AM
Thanks a lot Josh. I will include the example in the next post.

--
Regards
Parag

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Commenting your code

Comments are an integral part of any program, even though they do not contribute to the logic. Appropriate comments add to the maintainability of a software. I have heard developers complain about not remembering the logic of some code they wrote a few months back. Can you imagine how difficult it can be to understand programs written by others, when we sometimes find it hard to understand our own code. It is a nightmare to maintain programs that are not appropriately commented. Java classes should contain comments at various levels. There are two types of comments; implementation comments and documentation comments. Implementation comments usually explain design desicisions, or a particularly intricate peice of code. If you find the need to make a lot of implementation comments, then it may signal overly complex code. Documentation comments usually describe the API of a program, they are meant for developers who are going to use your classes. All classes, methods and variables ...

Inheritance vs. composition depending on how much is same and how much differs

I am reading the excellent Django book right now. In the 4th chapter on Django templates , there is an example of includes and inheritance in Django templates. Without going into details about Django templates, the include is very similar to composition where we can include the text of another template for evaluation. Inheritance in Django templates works in a way similar to object inheritance. Django templates can specify certain blocks which can be redefined in subtemplates. The subtemplates use the rest of the parent template as is. Now we have all learned that inheritance is used when we have a is-a relationship between classes, and composition is used when we have a contains-a relationship. This is absolutely right, but while reading about Django templates, I just realized another pattern in these relationships. This is really simple and perhaps many of you may have already have had this insight... We use inheritance when we want to allow reuse of the bulk of one object in other ...

Planning a User Guide - Part 3/5 - Co-ordinate the Team

Photo by  Helloquence  on  Unsplash This is the third post in a series of five posts on how to plan a user guide. In the first post , I wrote about how to conduct an audience analysis and the second post discussed how to define the overall scope of the manual. Once the overall scope of the user guide is defined, the next step is to coordinate the team that will work on creating the manual. A typical team will consist of the following roles. Many of these roles will be fulfilled by freelancers since they are one-off or intermittent work engagements. At the end of the article, I have provided a list of websites where you can find good freelancers. Creative Artist You'll need to work with a creative artist to design the cover page and any other images for the user guide. Most small to mid-sized companies don't have a dedicated creative artist on their rolls. But that's not a problem. There are several freelancing websites where you can work with great creative ...